Committee Takes Up Bills To Alter Or Repeal Proficiency-Based Diplomas For Maine Students

Apr 10, 2018

Parents, teachers and students packed the seats of a legislative hearing Monday to voice their opinions about two bills that would drastically change — or even repeal — Maine’s move toward proficiency-based diplomas.

Six years ago, legislators passed a law saying that for students to receive a diploma in Maine, they must reach proficiency in up to eight content areas ranging from English and math to health and art. This year’s freshmen are expected to be the first to graduate with the diplomas.

Over the past few months, lawmakers have heard from educators and officials concerned about the new diploma system, including that it could create a new, higher bar making it more difficult for some students — including those with disabilities — to graduate.

At Monday’s hearing, stakeholders weighed in on two bills. One, from the Department of Education, would only require students meet state standards in math and English to graduate. Another would repeal the proficiency-based diploma law completely. Lawmakers heard a third bill in February to delay the diplomas for another year.

Many students and teachers defended the proficiency-based model. Among them was Reese Pinkham, a middle school student who goes to school in Prospect Harbor.

“I credit proficiency-based education for really pushing me,” Pinkham says. “Letting me see what is next. Asking me if I’m ready to move ahead and try.”

Researchers at the University of Southern Maine told the committee that changing the state law would only affect graduation requirements and would still allow local schools to implement proficiency-based education and grading practices inside classrooms.

Others told the Education Committee that the state does need to change its diploma system. Andrew McKendry, a teacher at Forest Hills Consolidated School in Jackman — one of a few schools in the state that is set to graduate seniors with proficiency-based diplomas this year — says that while he supports many elements of proficiency-based education, requiring students to be proficient in eight subject areas is too onerous.

“It’s too many,” he says. “Pare that down some.”

McKendry shared the story of his daughter, who will graduate this year. He says that under his school’s proficiency-based grading system, his daughter may have ended up with a lower GPA, possibly affecting her chances at being accepted to some colleges.

“Could that have made a little bit of difference — because that picture may not be absolutely as good as it can be — because of this system?” he says. “I don’t know. And unfortunately my daughter will never know either.”

Lawmakers are scheduled to work on a path forward for the diplomas later this week. But they’ll need to work quickly to get a proposal to the House and Senate by April 18, when the Legislature is scheduled to adjourn.

This story was originally published April 9, 2018 at 5:15 p.m. ET.